Tips so you don’t end up in tax court for overcontributing to your RRSP

Article content material

The registered retirement financial savings plan (RRSP) deadline is simply two weeks away, so you might wish to double verify your contribution restrict for 2021 to assist decide whether or not you wish to sock some more cash away earlier than March 1.

Article content material

To help you, right here’s a refresher on RRSP deduction limits, some instruments you should use that can assist you calculate your potential 2021 tax financial savings, and a cautionary story from the courtroom the place a taxpayer made a expensive mistake when contributing to his RRSP primarily based on a misunderstanding of his contribution restrict.

Your restrict for 2021 begins along with your RRSP deduction restrict from 2020, since unused room is routinely carried ahead from 12 months to 12 months. Then, any RRSP contributions you deducted in your 2020 return are subtracted, earlier than including your new contribution room for 2021, equal to 18 per cent of 2020 “earned earnings,” to a most of $27,830. Earned earnings contains (self-)employment earnings and rental earnings, amongst a couple of different issues.

Article content material

The 18-per-cent limitation is tied into one thing referred to as the “issue of 9,” which makes use of a hypothetical defined-benefit pension plan wherein saving 9 per cent of an worker’s annual earnings will let a person purchase a retirement annuity equal to at least one per cent of pre-retirement earnings. The Tax Act lets a member of a defined-benefit pension plan accrue a most tax-free annuity of two per cent of ultimate earnings within the 12 months of accrual, which, over a 35-year working profession, would supply a pension equal to 70 per cent of pre-retirement earnings.

In the event you have been a member of a pension plan, you’ll have a 2020 pension adjustment deducted (you possibly can’t double up on whole financial savings) earlier than arriving at your 2021 RRSP deduction restrict. However that’s not essentially how a lot you possibly can contribute, as a result of, in some circumstances, you’ll have chosen to not deduct earlier RRSP contributions in a previous 12 months. For instance, should you contributed to an RRSP in 2020 when you have been on a parental depart and had little earnings, you’ll have determined to defer taking the deduction till a future 12 months. In these conditions, the undeducted contributions cut back the quantity you possibly can contribute for 2021.

Article content material

You’ll find your RRSP deduction restrict by visiting Canada Income Company’s My Account service on-line or by checking the RRSP Deduction Restrict Assertion in your most up-to-date discover of (re)evaluation.

There are a number of on-line instruments accessible that can assist you resolve how a lot to contribute. Intuit Inc.’s TurboTax affords an RRSP optimizer that exhibits how a lot your tax refund may improve (or tax owing lower) by making an RRSP contribution. Enter your earnings, tax paid thus far, and province and residence, and a slider permits you to mess around along with your RRSP contribution quantity as your refund (or legal responsibility) grows or shrinks. Accounting agency EY additionally has an RRSP calculator that may present what your RRSP contribution is price in all 10 provinces and territories, primarily based in your stage of taxable earnings.

Article content material

However, regardless of how a lot you resolve to contribute this RRSP season, it’s vital to remain inside your contribution restrict or face a penalty tax of 1 per cent per 30 days for every greenback you overcontribute (past a $2,000 permitted overage). A latest tax case determined final month concerned a taxpayer who was hit with the penalty tax for a mistaken RRSP overcontribution that stemmed from his misunderstanding of what constituted “earned earnings.”

In 2013, the taxpayer misplaced his job after 12 years of service along with his employer. He was sad with how he had been terminated and retained a lawyer. With the assistance of his counsel, the taxpayer negotiated a severance cost of roughly $165,000. He acquired this quantity in 2014 and included it in his taxable earnings. Throughout the 2015 RRSP season, particularly, in February of that 12 months, the taxpayer made an RRSP contribution of $24,270.

Article content material

Quick ahead three years to March 2018, and the CRA assessed the taxpayer an RRSP overcontribution penalty tax of $1,106 in respect of the 2015 taxation 12 months. The penalty tax was on simply a part of his RRSP contribution, since he did have some contribution room accessible.

The difficulty within the case got here down as to if the cost from his former employer fell throughout the definition of earned earnings for the aim of calculating his accessible room. If it did, there wouldn’t have been an overcontribution.

Article content material

The taxpayer maintained the cost shaped a part of his remuneration from employment. In spite of everything, he wouldn’t have acquired the quantity had he not been beforehand employed by the payor. Certainly, if the cost in problem was not remuneration and never earned earnings, then, he argued, he shouldn’t have been taxed on the cost in any respect.

That will have been true earlier than 1981, as prior jurisprudence concluded that such funds weren’t thought-about employment earnings. However, in late 1981, the definition of a “retiring allowance” was amended to incorporate the total quantity of any cost to an worker acquired as damages, or pursuant to a judicial dedication. Below the present wording, a retiring allowance is outlined as an quantity “acquired on or after retirement of a taxpayer from an … employment in recognition of the taxpayer’s lengthy service, or in respect of a lack of an workplace or employment of a taxpayer, whether or not or not acquired as, on account or in lieu of cost of, damages or pursuant to an order or judgment of a reliable tribunal.”

Article content material

Retiring allowances, nevertheless, are taxable as “different earnings,” not as employment earnings, and are subsequently excluded from the calculation of earned earnings that establishes RRSP room. Consequently, the taxpayer misplaced his case and was caught with the overcontribution penalty tax, which the choose did cut back considerably resulting from a computational error by the CRA.

Jamie Golombek, CPA, CA, CFP, CLU, TEP is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Non-public Wealth in Toronto. [email protected]

_____________________________________________________________

 For extra tales like this one, sign up for the FP Investor publication.

______________________________________________________________